Call Us (314) 645-6666

Case Results & News

Schedule Your No Obligation Consultation

Give Us a Call
(314) 645-6666


Fill out the form below

May 3, 2024

The Importance of Evidence in Personal Injury Cases

Whether navigating negotiations with insurance companies or presenting a case in court, the quality and quantity of evidence can significantly influence the outcome of all legal cases.

Understanding Evidence in Personal Injury Law
Evidence in personal injury cases encompasses all the tangible and intangible elements that substantiate the plaintiff’s claims of harm, liability, and the extent of damages suffered. It plays a pivotal role in:

  • Establishing Fault: Proving that the defendant’s actions or negligence directly caused the injury.
  • Demonstrating Impact: Showing the extent of the physical, emotional, and financial impact of the injury on the plaintiff’s life.
  • Calculating Damages: Justifying the amount of compensation sought by detailing the costs incurred and the value of losses suffered.

Types of Evidence in Personal Injury Cases

Physical Evidence
This includes any tangible items related to the incident or the injuries sustained. It can range from damaged personal property (e.g., a broken bicycle from a road accident) to clothing worn at the time of the incident. Physical evidence is powerful because it provides jurors and insurance adjusters with concrete, visual representations of the incident and its aftermath.

Photographic and Video Evidence
Images and videos from the scene of the incident, including those captured by surveillance cameras, dash cams, or bystanders, are invaluable. They can provide clear, undeniable depictions of the circumstances leading to the injury, the conditions at the scene, and the immediate consequences of the incident.

Medical Records
Documentation of injuries, diagnoses, treatments, and prognoses are crucial in personal injury cases. Medical records not only establish the direct physical effects of the incident but also contribute to calculating economic damages, including medical expenses and future care needs. Pleban & Associates will collect all of these records for you.

Witness Testimonies
Statements from people who witnessed the incident or can attest to the injury’s impact on the plaintiff’s life can strengthen a case significantly. Eyewitnesses can provide accounts that corroborate the plaintiff’s version of events, while friends, family, and employers can speak to the injury’s broader effects.

Expert Testimonies
Experts in fields such as medicine, accident reconstruction, and economics can offer specialized insights that support the plaintiff’s claims. For example, a medical expert can explain the extent of injuries and the necessity of treatments, while an accident reconstruction expert can help establish liability.

Documentation of Financial Losses
This encompasses records of all expenses and losses related to the injury, such as medical bills, repair or replacement of property, lost wages, and decreased earning capacity. Detailed financial documentation can help with claims for economic damages.

Collecting and Preserving Evidence

The success of a personal injury case often hinges on the ability to collect and preserve evidence promptly and effectively. Key strategies include:

  • Immediate Documentation: Photographing the scene and injuries as soon as possible after the incident can capture conditions that might change or be repaired.
  • Seeking Medical Attention: Beyond addressing health concerns, this ensures that injuries are officially recorded and attributed to the incident.
  • Gathering Information: Collecting contact details for witnesses and involved parties at the scene can be critical for later testimony.
  • Securing Professional Representation: Personal injury attorneys can provide invaluable guidance on what evidence is needed, how to collect it, and how to keep it safe. They can also help obtain evidence that might be difficult to access, such as surveillance footage or corporate records.

The Impact of Evidence on Case Outcomes

Strong evidence does more than just support a case in court. It also positions plaintiffs more favorably in settlement negotiations, often leading to more substantial compensation offers from insurance companies or defendants. In essence, comprehensive evidence not only bolsters the credibility of the plaintiff’s claims but also underscores the seriousness of their pursuit of justice, compelling opposing parties to consider the strength of the case being made against them.

Their is a legal adage that “evidence is king.” This holds particularly true in personal injury cases. A well-documented case, supported by a diverse collection of evidence, helps establish liability, demonstrating the impact of injuries, and securing rightful compensation. For individuals navigating the aftermath of an injury, understanding the importance of evidence and taking proactive steps to collect and preserve it can make all the difference in the pursuit of justice and recovery.

Submitting Your Information